Question:
Is it actually possible scientifically for a flag to blow on the moon?
anonymous
2008-04-26 06:13:00 UTC
Yeah yeah we landed on the moon we didn't blah blah, :) I just want to know about this one fact. Is it actually possible in the vacuum of space for a flag to blow on the moon? And if so or no please explain.
Sixteen answers:
A T
2008-04-26 07:41:53 UTC
Actually it can, but only on rare occassions, the reason for this, is the fact that there are phenomena, that occur on the moon that could create a moving temporary atmosphere, these are termed "transient lunar phenomena", (TLP's) and are a result of gas emmissions from the subsurface of the Moon, the cause is as yet unknown, for these things, but they are sometimes observed from Earth by binocular, and telescope observations, and rarely by eye sight alone, the rarity of these is high, but a number of them have been recorded, and the presence of Moon rock being found in remote regions suggest that in the past, the jets that happen were quite strong, resulting in this ejecta being forced past the gravitational balance point, between Earth and the Moon, but normally the answer would be no, but it would be a foolish person who would say that the only cause is the presence of an atmosphere, on any planet, or its absence, the indications are that many large bodies in space have these gas emmissions happening, and they can not be discounted as a motive force, albeit rare, the biggest problem is for a flag to survive, that is flexible enough to move and to deal with a temperature that reaches 130C it may also be possible to have happened on Mars in the distant past, as the ejecta from Mars rock has also been found in the arctic region, NASA actually has geologists, whose jobs include finding these, as far apart as the Arctic Circle to the Australian outback.
anonymous
2008-04-26 06:41:13 UTC
The flag was not waving, it was wobbling. It had a rod along the top to prevent it from sagging. it was made from some stiff material that folded out along the top rod. It was not common flag cloth. That was actually stated way back during the TV broadcast of one Moon expedition which I watched in living black and white. Might have been Apollo 15 or 16.



As the astronaut pushed the mast into the lunar soil, the flag wobbled. When he stopped pushing, the flag kept wobbling for a little longer than it would on Earth because there was no air, moving or still, to damp it's movement. Soon enough it stopped wobbling. It then remained still until either bumped by an astronaut or later when hit by the gas blast from the spacecraft leaving the Moon. Then it actually waved for a few seconds.



Video of the flag taken well after the mast was pushed into the ground show it was still, but slightly crumpled.



This objection by the Moon hoax liars is technically false and only takes commonsense observation to dismiss it. Nearly all the rest of their lies are the same, it only takes common sense or common knowledge of photography, radio or television to see they are lies.
AlienXXX
2008-04-26 06:21:33 UTC
A flag on the Moon cannot blow in the traditional way because there is no atmosphere, and therefore no wind.

We have all seen the american flag being planted on the moon and "waving away".

The official NASA explanation for this is that this was not a normal flag but a rather stiff one. It was designed this way because a normal flag would have simply hung down, spoiling the visual effect.

When it was stuck on the moon the vibration caused it to oscilate, causing the "waving effect".



or you can believe the conspiracy theories, if you prefer...
GeoffG
2008-04-26 06:20:06 UTC
No, it is not possible. The flags used on the Moon were rigged to give the appearance of blowing. There was a thin metal rod in the top seam of the flag which held it out straight. The astronauts handling the flag caused the flag pole to vibrate, which gave the appearance of the flag fluttering. But, no air, no wind.
?
2016-10-12 04:22:26 UTC
confident, I remember seeing the flag fall over basically on the sting of the exhibit screen because of the fact the Eagle blasted off. yet surprisingly each video I see now on DVD or on the internet of the takeoff has that area lacking. i assume somebody on intense products to what occurred to the flag. even though it continues to be there. It could not have been blasted off the moon because of the fact the blast became downwards removed from the lunar lander. It became the lander that left the moon. even though there are 5 different flags that have been planted a safer distance away and are nonetheless status.
alexgndl
2008-04-26 09:18:47 UTC
No, because there is no wind. When NASA first went to the moon, they actually stuck an iron rod into the flag so it would stay upright and look like it was blowing in the wind. That is what you see in all of the photos.
mansfield_bitter
2008-04-26 06:24:19 UTC
It can't blow but the vibrations set up in the pole when you dig it into the ground could have the same swaying effect which would go on for longer as there is no air resistance to stop the flag moving.
eeshadg
2008-04-26 06:53:09 UTC
A flag can't blow on the moon cause the moon has no atmosphere. Actually it doesn't have enough gravity to hold an atmosphere.
JOHNNIE B
2008-04-26 07:24:17 UTC
NASA is not an idiot,they new it would not stand out without something. So NASA put a support on the top edge of the flag. The wind is not blowing it.
anonymous
2008-04-26 08:35:11 UTC
On at least one of the Apollo missions to the moon, I can remember seeing the flag planted by the astronauts being blown around quite a bit by the rocket exhaust of the ascent stage, when they took off. So, yes, it's possible, but it doesn't ordinarily happen, unless there's a rocket nearby.
Sudha
2008-04-26 07:27:05 UTC
As the moon doesn't have any atmosphere or wind, the flags cannot blow or flutter
?
2008-04-26 06:21:09 UTC
Flags do not blow. The wind blows the flags!
bikenbeer2000
2008-04-26 06:27:58 UTC
No it isn't possible. For a flag to blow, molecules of gas must hit it. In a vacuum, there are no molecules of gas.
someone else
2008-04-26 06:16:42 UTC
Without air to move the flag, how can it blow?
Neda
2008-04-26 06:52:05 UTC
no its not possible

how can a flag blow in vacuumn?
anonymous
2008-04-26 11:34:29 UTC
no air means no blowing around



the astronut moved teh flag pole which made teh flag move



everybody know this


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...