Question:
I’m past an event horizon black hole I can’t avoid the singularity in my future world line?
?
2021-03-18 17:52:07 UTC
Who is to tell me I can’t escape the future being the singularity? 

When there’s a will there has to be a way out!  Jesse Jackson said we pulled the ceiling of impossibility so anything is possible!!! 

So I will fall to the singularity and the universe eternal existence will occur in the fraction of a second for me to fall into the singularity.... my future is certain ?!

I thought except for death and paying taxes nothing is certain .....   there HAS to be a way out !!!

What if the singularity all along had a wormhole right back to this universe and I re-enter ....  help me out .... I want to choose my future!  
Seven answers:
quantumclaustrophobe
2021-03-18 18:19:04 UTC
>>I’m past an event horizon black hole I can’t avoid the 

>>singularity in my future world line?

The closer you get to a black hole, the fewer options - or possibilities - you have. once you're *close* to the event horizon (without going past) - you're very likely already dead... so - whether there are *any* possibilities probably doesn't matter to you.  But, once you've gone past the event horizon, the possibilities dwindle. 



>>Who is to tell me I can’t escape the future being the singularity?

I think probably Kip Thorne can tell you that.  He probably has the best understanding of black holes - even beyond Stephen Hawking, in my opinion.  The matter making up your body will be 'destroyed' (his word), while maintaining the characteristic of mass; without anyway of accelerating to the speed needed to escape the event horizon,  the only option there is will be to continue to the singularity. 



>>When there’s a will there has to be a way out! 

This doesn't apply to *every* situation.. Even 'will' is limited by physics. 



>>Jesse Jackson said we pulled the ceiling of impossibility so 

>>anything is possible!!!

I don't think he was referencing anything remotely connected to escaping black holes... I think he was indicating pulling yourself out of poverty, out of a poor neighborhood, or out of a poor education... in those respects - he's right.  It just takes will to progress & improve; and the recognition of the path to take. 



>>So I will fall to the singularity and the universe eternal existence

>>will occur in the fraction of a second for me to fall into the singularity.... 

>>my future is certain ?!

Well - yes it is, but... the "you" of that you know now would pretty much cease to exist as you got close to the black hole. Your 'future' stopped a few kilometers on the other side of the Event Horizon - before you fell in. What happens after that point doesn't really matter anymore... 



>>I thought except for death and paying taxes nothing is certain ..... 

That's a saying; it's not an absolute. 



>>there HAS to be a way out !!!

**if** there is... we are unaware of it.  In theory, Hawking radiation would reduce the mass of the black hole; emitting this radiation back into the universe - so... it could be argued that leaving the black hole as Hawking radiation is one way out... Although it's probably not your first choice in how you'd prefer to vacate the property...



>>What if the singularity all along had a wormhole right back to 

>>this universe and I re-enter .... help me out .... I want to choose my future!

Wormholes are poppycock... yes, you can twist the math into one, but there'd be no guarantee that *all* of you would be able to exit through one, or that *all* of you would end up in the same place on the other side. Think of going though a cheese grater while in a paint shaker... 



>>Edit: also I took yoga classes and I’m getting more flexible so if there’s

>>“spaghettification” between gravity at my head and feet I will survive 

>>it .... I’m flexible my muscles will stretch like a contortion artist 

Sure.  You go with that. 
Nemo S
2021-03-20 19:19:24 UTC
Singularities increase not decrease the speed of an object to the point of being faster than light that is why they are called black holes it's an optical illusion everything beyond the event horizon is moving faster than light and that everything is quantum energy as all matter is reduced to it's base component and heat is also folded back into that place and so the illusion of cold is also present to the observers...



and there is only one REAL particle (Actually a particulate)  that survives this process it is what all other supposed particles are made from but they are just the wrapped quantum energies around this single particulate but they have several different characteristics due to the interaction of matter against energy since both are in motion and when fused together make up the elements ...

   

N.Shadows 
ANDRE L
2021-03-19 17:36:46 UTC
Would you like some balsamic dressing for that word salad ?
Ronald 7
2021-03-18 20:30:18 UTC
I found my answer on the End of a Joint
CarolOkla
2021-03-18 19:58:04 UTC
Please let us know what it feels like to have all your atoms ripped apart before you get to the singularity and if there really is a stable wormhole. 



Infinity, if you are young enough, why don't you apply for admission to the summer space camp. Maybe you will find out how misinformed you truly are and how speeding misinformation like you do harms EVERYONE. 
neb
2021-03-18 19:46:23 UTC
Remember, that not all black holes are the same (Kerr black holes rotate, Schwarzschild black holes do not) so you have to specify what kind of black hole you are talking about.



Unless specified, normally people default to Schwarzschild black holes. Kerr black holes are much, much more difficult to understand (it took 40 years after the Schwarzschild solution to get the Kerr solution). Keep in mind that although these are exact solutions of the field equations, unrealistic assumptions are made to make the solutions exact (as opposed to numerical simulation methods).



So, assuming a Schwarzschild black hole, once you are within the event horizon, all future paths lead to the singularity - assuming certain things. This is what Penrose just got a Nobel prize for. He proved for a Schwarszchild black hole with the so called dominant energy condition (all energy positive, no quantum gravity, no torsion, geodesics converging rather than diverging) then a singularity exists and all future paths terminate at the singularity. Again, it’s important to view the singularity as a termination of all future directed paths assuming the above conditions and assumptions.



Viewing it from a causal standpoint, the singularity cuts across the light cones (which specifies what regions of spacetime are causally connected to other regions) of ALL paths making it unavoidable without traveling back to the past (back toward the event horizon).



Number of other points:



Schwarzschild wormholes exist (in theory) for a vanishingly small time. They are unstable and not traversable.



Gravitational tidal forces for supermassive black hole are survivable for a human being since tidal forces are inversely proportional to the square of the mass of a black hole at the event horizon. However, You will inevitably reach a point within the event horizon that they will be so great you will be destroyed. Stellar black holes have incredible tidal forces at the event horizon and it’s not survivable to cross the event horizon.



It is a myth that you will see the entire life of the universe when falling into a black hole. You will see very little of the universe if you free fall through the event horizon. If you try to hover just above the event horizon using a rocket against the gravitational pull, you will see a portion of the universe go by quickly. You cannot hover AT the event horizon - only light can do that so there is no such thing as infinite time dilation for a material object.
anonymous
2021-03-18 18:45:25 UTC
If you were inside an event horizon, you wouldn't be able to communicate with us.

So either you are trying to be clever or you are deluded.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...