Be advised that there are almost as many starmaps in existence as there are stars! OK, I exaggerate, but there really are an awful lot of them! Norton's only goes down to around magnitude 6.0 or 6.5; Wil Tirion's goes down to I think, mag 8; others go deeper; some have millions of entries. The star you saw is guaranteed to be already charted, unless it is truly a nova or supernova. If it is one of those cataclysmic types, there are places to check for recent discoveries of such objects.
If you can make an accurate estimate of its magnitude and its location, try consulting some planetarium app -- I have one on my old Palm Tungsten PDA, called, "2Sky" ($); another on my iPhone called, StarMap Pro ($); and on my Mac I have Stellarium (free), which I strongly recommend for things like this.
You can download it free for either PC, Mac, or Linux, and then download (also free!) several successively deeper, more numerous starmaps, down to 18th magnitude!
StarMap on my iPhone, shows:
Schedar (spellings of star names sometimes vary) as α-Cas (brightest in Cassiopeia),
- at mag 2.2; RA=00:40:30, dec=56º32'15"
Tsih = γ-Cas, at mag 2.2; RA=00:56:43, dec=60º43'00"
And about ⅓ of the way from Schedar to Tsih is:
η-Cas, at mag 3.5; RA=00:49:05, dec=57º49'00"
which looks like it could be what you saw, but it is sure to be on *every* star chart. There are lots of dimmer stars in the area; I can't tell from this sparse info what you've found. But try looking into one of these other sources -- you might recognize it on one of them.
(If you're unfamiliar with Right Ascension and declination, they are a kind of spherical polar coordinate system on the sky, sort of like longitude and latitude, with RA measured in hr-min-sec from 00:00:00 to 23:59:59, increasing toward the east, and dec in degrees, north (+) or south(-) of the celestial equator. Try the Sky&Tel website for tutorials on this and other astro-basics, if needed.)